“I've been stagnant, I've been bored, think I've seen it all before”
- “I’ve Been Bored” by Superheaven
(click to listen)
The problem with making a sequel to a movie about the power and possibility of earthly salvation is that your main character was redeemed at the end of the last movie. The reclamation project is complete. There is nowhere to go emotionally. The only move you have is to make really big spectacle and hope nobody notices you’re doing the artistic equivalent of jangling keys in front of the camera and going, “LOOK AT THE SCARY MONSTER! LOOK AT THE SCARY MONSTER!”
This is exactly what’s happened with Godzilla Minus Zero, the peculiarly titled follow up to the peculiarly titled Godzilla Minus One, the Japanese-made 2023 reboot of the long-running famed multimedia franchise. I loved, loved, loved Minus One—in part because it snuck a poignant postwar kitchen sink realist drama about a failed kamikaze pilot overcoming survivor’s guilt and suicidal ideation into theaters by promising audiences they would get to see a nuclear-powered lizard blow up a city. I imagine the next film in the series will be called Godzilla Plus One and will be a romcom about Godzilla struggling to find a date to his ex’s wedding.
The characters from Godzilla Minus One return for this film, but having fully arced in the previous installment, there’s no reason for them to be here other than the director and producers thought the actors were easy to work with. There are affecting emotional beats carried out between these protagonists, but there is no overarching focus, and without a strong spine to tie everything together, many of these moments end up feeling mawkish, exploitative, and perfunctory. Between various attempts to amp up the melodrama, we are forced to watch characters do very little but discuss plot, the basics of which are extremely simple: A really big non-Godzilla monster is attacking Japan, a science bureau is stumped on how to prevent it. They carry out a really exciting action set piece that makes everything worse, and then Godzilla resurrects (out of nowhere and not due to the actions of our characters), so the bureau concocts a mad science infused scheme to contrive an inevitable CGI-laden final battle between the two creatures and then kill the weakened survivor.
There’s no denying that this clash is a visual treat. It’s also impossible to invest in. What does it matter which giant monster kills the other? Both creatures are characterized as insentient machines of wanton death and destruction. Whoever wins, humanity loses. I got the sense that the movie expects us to root for Godzilla, but I don’t know why. He killed thousands of civilians in the previous film, something this installment likes to flashback to in bloody detail. There is no sense of humanization, personality, or nuance of Godzilla as a character. The otherwise underwritten 2014 American Godzilla film managed to provide this, but the setup here makes the figure of Godzilla irredeemable because he isn’t alive. He’s a force of nature. A plot device.
Now I have to pause and do soul searching. Am I wrong to want emotional resonance from a movie whose title character is a thermonuclear dinosaur? Am I asking for too much? Am I doing the equivalent of walking into a burger joint and slapping a tray out of a waiter’s hands because he’s serving double deckers with cheese and not filet mignon? Maybe the movie isn’t the problem. Maybe I am. Maybe I’m just a wet blanket perennially stricken with anhedonia—a buzzkill from Buzzkill Island, capital city of the People’s Republic of Buzzkillistan. Perhaps I should get on cocktail of Lexapro, Seroquel, and whatever the fuck laughing gas Jimmy Fallon is on so I can join the mongrel hordes of moviegoers whose reactions to movies are limited to “IT WAS GOOD,” “IT WAS OKAY,” and “IT SUCKED ASS.” I presume my insurance would cover the treatment and I wouldn’t feel compelled to write 800 words trying to explain how I felt watching light reflect off a wall while stuffing my mouth with so much popcorn I’ve permanently ruptured my bowels.
Or perhaps I simply have tastes and standards. And maybe this movie did not need to be over two hours and would have been better served by abandoning its pretensions, aiming to be a tight 90 minutes, or at the very least introducing a new human cast. Maybe, just maybe, I’m not someone who can be dismissed as a cantankerous pessimist, but a musician who knows what he likes and whose instrument is the selective deployment of verbal bile. What is it I like, you ask? Well, it’s very simple. Something like the Godzilla movie that preceded this one. Give me filet mignon served on a bun with ketchup, lettuce, and tomato, with broccoli on the side. And fries. But not those pretentious skinny fries. Do I look French to you?


